Well here’s a Kylie Jenner makeup video nobody saw coming—and yet it’s a strong contender for our favorite one so far. In the latest post to go up on her subscription-only website TheKylieJenner.com, the reality/social media star shared not another one of her popular tutorials, but a video of her two best guy friends doing her makeup. And no, they’re not makeup-artist friends (as celebrities are known to roll with in their squads); these are just regular guy friends with, presumably, zero previous experience contouring a cheek or applying eyeliner.

Taking into consideration just how badly this experiment could go—and how badly it would go if most of our own male friends were involved—Jenner’s pals Harry Hudson and Josh Woods did an admirable job. Jenner got her pals set up in her famous dedicated glam room, then watched in a hand-held mirror as they applied foundation, brow pencil, blush, eyeshadow, lip liner, concealer, and even highlighter. Jenner can’t stop giggling throughout the video, but we were seriously impressed with Harry and Josh’s technique, especially their dual-action sponge/brush foundation blending and their one-dude-on-each-brow arch definition method. Their clueless commentary is even more endearing than their skills are impressive. “Can you hand me my next utensil?” Harry asks at one point. “So with the blush…you put it on the cheeks?” Josh asks. “I think I’m going to cry,” Jenner says at one point.

A video posted by King Kylie (@kyliejenner) on Feb 1, 2016 at 10:55am PST

But Jenner’s verdict, as she snaps the requisite selfies post-makeup, is a good one: “This doesn’t look that bad. You guys, how good does my face look? I’m not kidding.” Other than some questionable smoky-eye blending, we agree—she could possibly even leave the house without anyone noticing something was really off. This video makes us appreciate Jenner’s sense of humor, and we’re big fans of Makeup by Josh and Makeup by Harry and hope they’re enjoying their newfound fame today. We wonder if we’ll see a for-real makeup tutorial from them in the not-so-distant future; far more shocking things have happened in the Kardashian-Jenner realm.

Just check out this transformation:





Download Jenner’s app or check out her website to watch the whole thing unfold.

Watch 13 Weirdly Entertaining Facts About the Jenners and Kardashians: